What does it take to diversify? Reconceptualizing Indonesia’s food systems using the mangrove metaphor

Through five key elements, the mangrove metaphor illustrates how diversification expands choices, strengthens connections, and enhances the food system’s capacity to respond to change.

Photo by Orpita Akther Ratna / Unsplash

As an archipelagic nation with diverse landscapes, Indonesia is home to a wealth of natural resources, ecosystems, traditions, and dietary practices that shape its food diversity. Yet, a diversity of food sources does not necessarily translate into a diverse food system.

Today, despite this abundance, our food systems face what is known as a polycrisis: climate change, biodiversity loss, food insecurity, diet-related chronic diseases, inequality, and economic and geopolitical disruptions that are deeply interconnected. These crises do not occur in isolation. When one part of the system is disrupted, the effects can ripple through the others.

To understand such complexity, we need metaphors that help us see relationships that are difficult to grasp when systems are presented merely as collections of data or isolated components.

For example, sustainability has long been represented through the metaphor of three pillars: environmental, social, and economic. While the three-pillar model suggests that each dimension can stand independently, food systems are dynamic socio-ecological systems in which every component influences the others. In other words, this framework may no longer be sufficient to capture the complexity of food systems.

In response, a group of researchers proposed a more living metaphor: the mangrove ecosystem.


Why a mangrove ecosystem?

Mangroves thrive in harsh and ever-changing environments, contending with saltwater, low oxygen levels, and the constant rhythms of the tides. Yet, they endure through their ability to adapt. Their complex root systems also mean that mangroves do not exist as isolated individuals. Instead, they form part of an ecosystem that supports biodiversity, fisheries, carbon sequestration, and a range of other ecological functions.

This is where the metaphor gains its strength: mangroves demonstrate how resilience emerges from diversity, interconnectedness, and the capacity to adapt.

Within this framework, a food system is imagined as a mangrove tree. Food system activities, from production to waste recovery, form the living bark of its trunk, fed by five root systems. Above them are the leaves: the outcomes a food system aims to deliver, such as health and well-being, nutrition, food security, dignified livelihoods, education, a habitable environment, and agency, equity, and justice. Different communities may define these outcomes for themselves.

The first root, the agroecosystem, is the ecological base on which food is grown, including crops, animals, soils, water, and landscapes. The second, governance, concerns food policy and decision-making that shape food systems' direction. Here, goals should not be set by a few. The third, the economic system, encompasses markets, infrastructure, supply chains, and livelihoods, which need enough variety that the system does not depend on a single pathway. The fourth root, the dietary system, covers not only what we eat but also what is available, affordable, and accessible within Indonesia’s food environments. Finally, the knowledge system spans the knowledge, skills, cultural meanings, social networks, and food literacy that shape how we understand and relate to food.

Interwoven, these five roots show that food is never just about what ends up on our plates.

Diversification as the root of resilience

Across these five roots, diversification lies at the heart of the framework. But diversification does not simply mean making a system bigger or adding more variety. It is an ongoing process of cultivating socio-ecological complexity and opening up new possibilities across different parts of the food system, giving it more options and greater capacity to adapt.

In Indonesia, this perspective can change how we understand food diversification. It goes beyond substituting one ingredient for another. It asks why our food production, distribution, knowledge, policies, and consumption have come to depend on certain choices, while existing alternatives do not always receive the same space or support.

Consider a system that relies on a single crop, distribution route, producer group, dietary pattern, or source of knowledge. Such a system may operate efficiently under normal conditions, but it is more exposed when disruptions occur.

A system with a wider range of crops, producers, distribution networks, knowledge systems, and dietary choices has more ways to respond to change.

However, greater diversity also brings greater complexity, making the system more difficult to predict. Diversification therefore calls for an ongoing process of monitoring, evaluation, adjustment, and learning.

And as with mangroves, no single root can function in isolation. Changes in agricultural systems affect the economy and dietary patterns, policy shifts influence producers and consumers, and changes in knowledge can transform how we perceive food.

If diversity and interconnectedness can strengthen resilience, why does Indonesia’s food system remain largely uniform?

One reason may be a production model built around plantation monocultures and a handful of strategic commodities. Despite relatively high productivity in plantation crops, Indonesia still relies on imports to meet its food needs. Between 2019 and 2023, imports accounted for 40.08% of food crops, 21.29% of livestock products, and 10.85% of horticultural products.

Our study also points to agricultural policies that place rice at the center of development, with rice, corn, and soybeans serving as the primary benchmarks of success. This one-size-fits-all approach risks overlooking specific regional conditions and the potential of other staple foods, leaving local food diversity underutilized.

Lastly, shifting this pattern requires time, collaboration, and a new mindset. Indonesia already has policy frameworks to support food diversification, including Presidential Regulation No. 22/2009 and Presidential Regulation No. 81/2024. The challenge is to untangle interconnected barriers, from food availability and affordability, perceptions and eating habits, and coordination across institutions.

Diversification can gain momentum when policies, practices, and networks of stakeholders move together to broaden food choices and strengthen the resilience of the food system.


At the end, the authors call for a transdisciplinary approach. Experts in agriculture, health, nutrition, economics, policy, and education, alongside community actors, can no longer work in silos; we belong to the same ecosystem. Mangroves do not thrive because of one exceptionally strong root, but because many adaptations work together. Resilient food systems may be no different.

 

References:

  • Baur, P., Petersen-Rockney, M., Bowles, T., & Ahmed, S. (2025). A mangrove metaphor for sustainable food systems centres diversification as the root of human and planetary health. Nature Food, 6(6), 539–546. https://doi.org/10.1038/s43016-025-01185-0

  • foodagogik (2024): Imagining the future of Indonesian food systems. foodagogik. Jakarta: foodagogik.

Previous
Previous

After Pranata Mangsa: Indonesian art collectives and the governance of food and climate catastrophe

Next
Next

What, how, and why we eat is a climate and health policy that deserves attention